whites educating whites (so POC don't have to)

"Apparel manufacturer The Gap is currently selling a black t-shirt bearing — with no explanation — the words “MANIFEST DESTINY.” Manifest Destiny is a polite term for the popular 19th-century belief that the United States — a white, European nation — was destined to expand westward across the continent, by any means necessary. In Indian country, the term Manifest Destiny calls to mind the suffering of previous generations of Natives through forced relocation and genocide.”

—from Indian Country Today Media Network (full article here)

On the left is an altered ad campaign image for The Gap’s new pro-genocide statement t shirt, bearing the words “Manifest Destiny.” On the right is a response from the Settler Colonial facebook page. The designer, Mark McNairy, issued a non-apology on twitter—something along the lines of “I’m sorry you thought I was racist”—after he tweeted “MANIFEST DESTINY. SURVIVAL OF THE FITTEST.” Sure, these are both racist white ideas, but they mean very different things. Manifest Destiny is more so “survival of the whitest.” The philosophy behind it also involved European colonialism and genocide of Indigenous peoples being sanctioned by “God,” which doesn’t quite work with a scientific theory of evolution. If white folks don’t know the meaning of Manifest Destiny, we don’t get to create a new one that we imagine is completely separate from its specific historical and social context. 

For whites to wear the Gap original, it would be continuing our long legacy of racist disregard for Indigenous peoples, our appropriation of violent ideas (or violent appropriation as an act in and of itself) to make a fashion statement, and our privilege of never knowing the harm of racist ideas and language. Folks with white skin are repeat offenders when it comes to cultural theft, and it may seem acceptable, innocuous, or even meaningless because we have absolutely no idea what that experience is like. There are no t shirts printed with statements signifying the genocide, removal, displacement, colonization, and mass killing of white folks. There are also no corporate megastores selling shirts that say “Auschwitz” or “Sieg Heil.” It’s only because of our positions on the safe and privileged (therefore ignorant) side of Manifest Destiny that we can have fun with the term and turn it into a consumer product. The good news is that The Gap has apparently agreed to stop selling the shirt. The bad news is that racism doesn’t go out of style with it.

  1. witknitch reblogged this from moo-ahyou
  2. moo-ahyou reblogged this from whatfreshhellisthis
  3. mihaelkai reblogged this from whatfreshhellisthis and added:
    What the hell, GAP? Seriously???
  4. grimdominatrix reblogged this from reverseracism
  5. redmooseridingweirdo reblogged this from reverseracism
  6. iamkiam reblogged this from reverseracism
  7. doctorcrazygirlchic reblogged this from reverseracism
  8. tawdryplaza reblogged this from reverseracism
  9. coolhandsami reblogged this from reverseracism
  10. pillowthots reblogged this from reverseracism
  11. reverseracism reblogged this from whiteseducatingwhites
  12. glasskaleidoscope reblogged this from whatfreshhellisthis
  13. p0tt3r-10v3r reblogged this from shallanelprin
  14. sandetiger reblogged this from whatfreshhellisthis
  15. donutpanic reblogged this from all-tsun-and-no-dere
  16. pinksputnik reblogged this from danikasapphistry
  17. truthaboutdesire reblogged this from boyexemplified
  18. shallanelprin reblogged this from whatfreshhellisthis and added:
    WHAT. THE. ACTUAL. FUCK?!! I AM DISAPPOINT GAP, NOT OKAY.
  19. boyexemplified reblogged this from whatfreshhellisthis and added:
    I can’t even begin to comprehend what goes through the heads of some people.
  20. all-tsun-and-no-dere reblogged this from whatfreshhellisthis and added:
    Jesus Christ gap. I’m running out of places where I can shop.
  21. whatfreshhellisthis reblogged this from danikasapphistry and added:
    what the ACTUAL SHIT IS WRONG WITH THESE AWFUL PEOPLE
  22. danikasapphistry reblogged this from whiteseducatingwhites
  23. thats-so-killer-croc reblogged this from whiteseducatingwhites
  24. whiteseducatingwhites posted this